JA/ENTalk to us

Quality control

What is cleaning quality control? A complete guide to verifying outsourced cleaning

Cleaning quality control means checking that cleaning is done to the standard you set, fixing any gaps you find, and checking again that they are fixed.

It works the same way whether you clean with your own staff or outsource to cleaning companies or individuals. This guide covers the four steps of quality control, the pros and cons of each way to check, and what to put in the contract. Each section links to a more detailed article.

Why cleaning quality control is hard

Cleaning quality control is hard because the client cannot easily see the cleaning work.

  • After cleaning, the first people to see the place are guests or users. Guests often end up being the first to find problems.
  • “Done” is decided by the person who cleaned. A word does not show how much was actually done.
  • As sites and rooms increase, managers can no longer go and see every cleaning.

The people who clean have a problem too: clean places are taken for granted, and only mistakes get noticed. Invisibility hurts both the client and the people who clean.

More detail: Cleaning work goes unappreciated because it is invisible

The four steps of quality control

1. Set the standard

First, set the standard for “done” in a form you can check. Instead of “clean it,” use items anyone can confirm by looking, such as “no dirt inside the toilet bowl” or “trash can empty, with a new bag.”

Write the standard in specifications or checklists, and also show the steps on video so they are easier to understand. When each site or room needs attention in different places, add items just for that place.

2. Verify the work was done

Next, confirm that the cleaning was done at the agreed place and time. This is work verification. When local governments in Japan outsource cleaning, the way to verify the work is set out in manuals.

Check who cleaned, when, and where. Comparing the schedule (shifts) with the actual reports reveals cleanings that did not happen, or cleanings with no report after the scheduled time.

More detail: What is cleaning work verification?

3. Inspect that it meets the standard

Even if cleaning was done, it means little if it falls short of the standard. Check the finished cleaning item by item against the standard. This is inspection.

In building cleaning in Japan, training courses for inspectors use a “work quality sheet” that lists, for each work area, the items to evaluate and the points to look at (a research report funded by Japan’s Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare, in Japanese). The key is to decide the items and points in advance, so the result does not depend on who inspects.

4. Fix and measure again

When you find a problem, check the cause and fix it. What matters is to measure again the same way after fixing. Because you use the same yardstick, you can tell whether the problem went down.

Guest reviews, complaints, and records of discounts and refunds are clues for finding problems. If you turn a comment like “there was trash left” into a number, such as the rate of trash complaints, you can make it a goal for improvement.

Pros and cons of each way to check

Way to check Pros Cons
Manager site visits You see the result with your own eyes Limited number of visits. You only know about the days you visit
Photo reports You see the result without going to the site Hard to catch photos with the wrong time or place, or reused photos
Paper or Excel checklists Items are consistent, and anyone checks in the same order You cannot tell whether someone really checked on site
Systems that check reports automatically Every report is matched against time, place, and schedule Takes some work up front to set the standard and items to check

No single method can check everything. If you screen every report automatically and send people only where there are problems, you can keep quality up with fewer people.

The people side: when staff stay, quality stays steady

Cleaning quality depends on the people who do the work. When staff change often, you have to retrain each time, and quality varies. Building a workplace where people do not quit, for example by analyzing why people leave or creating shorter shifts, is also part of quality control.

At the same time, if you keep the standard with each site rather than with each person, quality is less likely to drop when people change.

More detail: What do companies that keep their cleaning staff do?

What to put in the contract

When you outsource cleaning, agree on quality control matters in the contract up front.

  • Standard: which places to clean, and to what level (specifications or checklists)
  • Reports: who reports, when, and in what form (photos, video, checklists, and so on)
  • When the standard is not met: how re-cleaning and discounts are handled

Because cleaning results are easy to judge by eye, contracts sometimes include free re-cleaning or discount clauses (an explainer by Money Forward, in Japanese). Check the form of your contract with a professional as well.

Toreshiru’s view

Toreshiru puts cleaning staff and owners on the same page. Cleaning staff just scan the QR code at each site and take photos. Toreshiru checks the place, time, and photos against the scheduled shifts, and works with you until the numbers show the problem is fixed.

Put cleaning staff and owners on the same page (Toreshiru)

FAQ

What is cleaning quality control?

It means checking that cleaning is done to the standard you set, fixing any gaps you find, and checking again that they are fixed. It has four steps — set the standard, verify that the work was done, inspect that it meets the standard, and fix and measure again.

What is the difference between work verification and inspection?

Work verification confirms that the contracted cleaning was done at the agreed time and place. Inspection confirms that the finished cleaning meets the standard. Quality control needs both.

Are photo reports enough for quality control?

Photos alone are sometimes not enough. Photos taken at a different time or place, or the same photo as last time, are hard to catch by eye. Checking the time and place of each photo against the schedule makes reports trustworthy.

We have too many sites for managers to visit them all. What should we do?

Screen every report automatically, and send people only to the sites with problems. This keeps quality up with fewer people.

All columns